If your cold outreach is not working, one of three things is broken: your emails are not reaching the inbox (Reach), the right buyers have no reason to reply (Reason), or interested replies are not being turned into meetings (Reply). Check them in that order, because a better message cannot fix a spam problem. Reachly runs this check on every campaign, and one marketing agency client built this way averaged an 8% positive reply rate across its campaigns.
Key Findings
- Cold outreach breaks in one of three places: Reach (the inbox), Reason (the offer and the list) or Reply (what happens after someone answers).
- Check Reach first. If emails land in spam, every rewrite of the copy is tested on nobody.
- Reachly pauses a mailbox when its reply rate drops under 0.5%, its warm-up score falls under 95% or bounces pass 2%.
- An angle with zero positive replies after 1,000 emails, while out of office replies prove you are inboxing, is an offer problem.
- A specific offer helped one agency client reach an 8% positive reply rate, 85+ SQLs and 6 new deals in 6 months.
- A prospect who says yes to your research has agreed to the research. Send it first and ask a question before suggesting a meeting.
- Someone has to own every reply. One co-working client closed a $250K+ contract from a conversation kept alive for months.
Thibault Garcia, Reachly's founder, walks through all three checks in the 7-minute video below. The written version follows it, with the thresholds we use on client campaigns and a checklist you can tick off.
Jump to a section of the video:
- 0:00 Why your campaign gets no replies
- 0:55 Reach: are your emails landing in the inbox?
- 1:47 Reason: why should they care?
- 3:59 Reply: what happens after they answer
- 6:00 Recap: the 3 Rs
- 6:17 Does outbound make sense for you?
- 6:28 Get a free outbound audit
Why is your cold outreach not working?
We see the same story from companies that come to Reachly after running outbound themselves. A campaign goes out to 2,000 people and a week later there are zero replies. So the subject line gets rewritten. Nothing. Then the opening line. Nothing. Then another 10,000 contacts go in. Still nothing. Finally someone runs a test and finds most of those emails were landing in spam. Every version was good enough to judge, and nobody ever saw them.
The cause is usually spam, or it is the offer and the copy, and teams keep fixing the wrong one. Reachly splits the problem into three checks, which we call the 3 Rs, and runs them in a fixed order.
The order matters because each problem hides the next one. A Reach problem tells you nothing about your offer, and a Reason problem leaves you no replies to handle. Follow the line down and stop at the first no.
How do you know if your cold emails are reaching the inbox?
Reach comes down to one question: do you have proof that people are receiving your emails? If the honest answer is “I'm not sure”, start here, before you judge a single line of copy.
Imagine you open a shop and nobody walks in. Before you redesign the window, you probably want to check whether the shop is on the street where people actually walk down. If your emails go to spam, every rewrite is a new window display on an empty street. You learn nothing.
What to set up before the first send
Reachly sets up three things on every campaign. Separate domains for outreach, so the main company domain stays safe. Mailboxes set up properly and warmed for 4 weeks before anything goes out. And sending volume that rises slowly, never all at once. Our cold email deliverability playbook covers each step, from authentication records to warm-up.
What to watch once it is running
A mailbox that worked well last month can stop working this month. When that happens, pause it and find out why before you send more. Reachly runs these four checks on every sending mailbox, and pulls any mailbox that misses a pass line.
- 1Open the campaign statsRead the overall reply rate per mailbox, out of office replies includedPass: above 0.5%
- 2Run an inbox placement testSend to seed inboxes on Gmail and Outlook and count where they landPass: most in the inbox
- 3Check the bounce rateFor each sending mailboxPass: under 2%
- 4Check the warm-up scoreIn your warm-up tool, for every sending mailboxPass: 95% or higher
We watch reply rate first because out of office replies only come back from inboxes, so it is the earliest sign of trouble. An inbox placement test then confirms it. About 30% of our sending infrastructure stays in reserve, so a paused mailbox is swapped out without slowing the campaign. On the Gmail side, Google's sender guidelines ask bulk senders to keep the spam rate in Postmaster Tools below 0.3%.
Try this before you touch the copy: look for out of office replies, run a placement test and check your bounce rate. If all three look healthy, Reach passes and the next check is the offer.
Why would the right buyer reply to your cold outreach?
Put yourself in the reader's position for a second. They are busy, with clients, deadlines and a team asking questions all day. Then a stranger messages them, explains their company, lists their services and asks for 30 minutes. That is like someone stopping you on the street and asking for half an hour before they even say why. Most people keep walking.
So Reachly builds every campaign around a clear reason to reply, in two steps.
Step one: who could actually buy
Who has the problem, who can afford the service, and who is involved in the decision. Thibault's pre-launch check is that at least 90% of the people on the list are actually relevant to the offer. In his words, the list is the copy: a well-written email sent to the wrong person still gets no reply.
Step two: why reach out now
A new marketing hire, a funding round or a problem we can see in their business. A signal is only a starting point, though. A company that just raised money does not automatically need your service, so the message has to connect the dots for them. Our guide to trigger-based outreach ranks which signals are worth acting on.
- 1List who could actually buyThey have the problem, can afford the fix and are part of the decisionPass: 90% of the list fits
- 2Find a reason to reach out nowA new hire, a funding round or a problem you can see in their businessPass: you can say why this company, this week
- 3Offer something useful for a one-word yesResearch, a short audit or a list they would want, done before you sendPass: the reader knows what they get by replying
Two messages from the same agency
One of our clients, a marketing agency, relied on paid ads to win new clients, and ads were getting more expensive. For one angle we looked at search. We searched terms their prospects cared about, such as manufacturing in Singapore, and noted who showed up. If a prospect was missing from page one, we had something specific to talk about. Compare the message we sent with the one most agencies send.
The first one tells the reader exactly what they get by replying. It also commits you: if you offer research, you have to have done it before you send. That agency is Primal, and the numbers below cover all of its campaigns, of which the search angle was one. One message will not perform the same in every market. What carries over is the way of thinking about the offer.
How to tell the offer is the problem
Reachly stops testing an angle when it reaches 1,000 emails with zero positive replies while the overall reply rate shows the emails are landing. The same goes when replies are mostly “no thanks” or “not interested”. People are reading the email, so everything technical works, and the offer is what needs rebuilding. For angles that have booked meetings, see our cold email offer examples.
Try this before you add more contacts: answer three questions. Why this company? Why this person? What can you say that gives them a useful reason to answer? If any answer is vague, fix it first.
What should you do after a prospect replies to cold outreach?
Say the agency's prospect writes back: “Yes, please send it over.” A lot of teams get excited at this point and reply with a calendar link straight away. Remember that this person said yes to your research. They have not agreed to a call.
Send what you promised, then ask a question
Send the actual research first, then ask something they can answer in one line: “These are the three sites ahead of you for that search. Are you already working on this, or is it a lower priority right now?” Now you get an answer you can actually work with.
Answer each reply differently
- 1“We tried SEO last year and it didn’t work.”They care, and they have been burnedNext: ask what they tried
- 2“We’ve been meaning to look at it.”It matters, just not this quarterNext: find out when it might come back up
- 3“We’re actively looking for help.”It is a priority nowNext: “We could walk you through the gaps and what we’d tackle first. Would a short call next week help?”
By the time you suggest a call, the meeting feels like the obvious next step to the prospect, which is when it gets booked.
Someone has to own every reply
This only works if someone owns the reply. Reachly tracks every conversation. “Come back next month” is written into the CRM with a follow-up date. “Send more info” triggers a follow-up carrying the case studies or a lead magnet. “Not interested” gets a do-not-contact tag. And if someone already replied on LinkedIn, the next email knows it.
Some deals take a lot longer. One of our clients, The Great Room, sells premium co-working space, where Thibault puts the sales cycle at around six months: buyers have a lease, a budget to confirm or other people to convince. We followed up on every reply before handing conversations to their sales team, and about nine months in, one of those conversations closed as a contract worth more than $250,000. Our part was starting the conversation and keeping it alive.
So an interested reply does not always mean book the meeting now. Work out where the buyer is and agree on the next step. Try this: open your last 20 replies and sort them into three piles, confused, interested but not ready, and ready. That tells you more than any dashboard. For the sequence itself, our cold email follow up guide has the templates we use.
Does outbound make sense for your business at all?
Before any of the three checks, ask whether outbound fits. Is your market big enough? Is a new client worth enough to justify the work? Can you say clearly who you help and why they buy? If any answer is no, fixing Reach, Reason or Reply will not rescue the channel.
If the answers are yes and results are still flat, the problem is in one of the 3 Rs. Reachly's cold email agency team runs this audit on existing campaigns, looking at your market, your outreach, the infrastructure setup and everything that happens after people reply. It is also how every outbound lead generation engagement starts.
Which checks should you run on your campaign this week?
Work down the list in order and stop at the first box you cannot tick. That is the R to fix.
FAQ
Does cold outreach actually work?
Yes, when the offer is strong and the sending setup is sound, but plan for testing. Thibault calls cold email a marketing experiment, the same as running Meta ads: you test the offer, angle, call to action, copy and audience until one converts into meetings, and that takes trial and error. For The Great Room, outbound took face-to-face meetings from about 2 a quarter to about 2 a month. Our guide to what cold email is covers the legal rules that apply in 2026.
What is the success rate of cold emails?
Thibault's ballpark is a 1 to 4% overall reply rate, depending on volume, with 10 to 30% of those replies positive, depending on the offer. Another way to plan it is one positive reply for every 400 to 600 emails sent. Our cold email response rate benchmarks compare published figures by source.
How long should you wait for a cold email response?
Reachly waits 5 to 6 days before the follow-up, so the second email lands on a different day of the week. If neither email gets a reply, the sequence ends there. Around a month and a half to two and a half months later, the same prospects get a new sequence with new messaging.
How many times should you follow up on a cold email?
Once. Reachly sends 2 emails per sequence, because longer sequences raise the chance that people report you as spam. The follow-up that earns the most replies is one line: “Would this be something of interest, or does {subject} sit with {colleague_name}?” People who still do not reply get a LinkedIn message instead of a third email.
How many cold emails can you send a day?
Reachly sends 12 to 15 emails per mailbox per day, with no more than 15 on Google Workspace and 10 to 12 on Outlook, from 2 to 3 mailboxes per domain. Total volume grows by adding domains and mailboxes while each mailbox stays under that ceiling. Sending 5,000 cold emails a day walks through the math for high volume.
How long should cold outreach emails be?
Short enough to read on a phone screen in one go. Thibault's test is to read the email out loud: if it does not sound like the way a person speaks, or the reader has to work to understand it, cut it down. We explain the length we write to in why cold emails should be 70 to 80 words.












